Wireless Computing
Search

 

 

 

NOT ALL RF UNITS THE SAME. HERE'S WHAT TO LOOK FOR WHEN YOU PURCHASE

by Don Kreski, Systems Contractor News, April, 2007

HANCOCK COUNTY, MS—Stennis Space Center is NASA’s base in southwestern Mississippi for testing rocket engines. Since opening, they have tested engines for every NASA vehicle, including the space shuttle. They will soon begin work on the engines for the space shuttle replacement that is planned for debut in 2010.

Shelby Russell, lead audio visual technician at Stennis Space Center, feels there are four critical components needed in a wireless keyboard or mouse used in conferences. He’s developed the list after two years of experience with keyboards from various manufacturers in the conference rooms he supports.

Russell and three other technicians support extensive AV systems in a visitor’s center and 30 plus conference rooms located in various buildings across the center. These rooms are accessible to the Rocket Propulsion Testing Group and NASA’s Applied Research and Technology Project, as well as research programs of the U.S. Navy, the National Oceanic & Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), Environmental Protection Agency and other government agencies.

Russell says he began purchasing wireless keyboards for use in what center personnel call their working meetings. In these meetings, engineers, administrative, or IT staff get together to work on a drawing, database or other document; and they pass the keyboard and mouse around as various people contribute. “For safety and convenience reasons we really didn’t want cables running across the floor,” says Russell, “so I started shopping for wireless.” Here’s what Russell learned is most important in this type of system:

Number 1: operating range

Russell says he started out with one or two consumer keyboards that he bought at a local electronics store. “Most of these keyboards have a range of only six feet or so, and since the conference tables are all at least six feet from the computer, that really didn’t work out too well.” The other problem he found is that some consumer keyboards communicate with the computer via an infrared signal that’s line of site, so as soon as someone steps between the presenter and the computer or if the keyboard is not aimed toward the receiver, it stops working.

Number 2: ID address memory and interference

Russell soon found a manufacturer of radio-frequency (RF) keyboards, which eliminated the line-of-sight problem and had a range of about 30 - 100 feet, depending on the model.

He says these seemed to work well at first, but he bumped into another, quite unexpected problem. “In order to save battery power the mouse would go into a sleep mode after about 30 minutes if it wasn’t used. The average user didn’t know that it was asleep, so they’d just try moving the mouse, which was not what was needed to wake it up. Oftentimes at that point they’d take the batteries out and put new batteries in, which caused an even greater problem.”

In any installation with multiple conference rooms, you need to set each wireless keyboard and mouse to its own digital address. If you don’t, a user in one room will start to control the computer in another and have his computer controlled or interfered with by the user next door. Russell says the keyboards and mice he purchased would drop back to their default address as soon as the batteries were changed. If that happened to one keyboard, it might be OK, but as soon as a second user needed to replace his batteries, both systems would go down. “We were having to run around to the various conference rooms at least twice a week to reset these addresses,“ Russell says. “That was a big waste of our time and the users’ time.”

Number 3: two-way communications

“One of other things that happened with these keyboards,” Russell says, “was that someone would be typing away and look up at the screen and notice there were missing characters. Of course, everybody else in the room would think the person on the keyboard couldn’t type, but that wasn’t the problem.” With most RF keyboards, communication is only one way. The keyboard sends a character and you just hope or assume that the computer receives it. But if there’s any kind of RF interference, characters drop out. What’s needed is enough logic in the system that the keyboard sends a character and the receiver very quickly replies that it got it. If the keyboard doesn’t get the appropriate response, it sends the keystroke again. “Once we purchased keyboards with two way communications, the chances became very slim if at all of having missed characters.”

Number 4: encryption

One potential disadvantage of an RF keyboard is security. Radio signals travel through walls, and it’s not hard for someone to pick up unsecured keystrokes from the next room or even from a different building. “I don’t think it was really a problem with the older keyboards,” says Russell, “but since NASA and Navy personnel are having meetings containing sensitive information, we’re really glad to have switched to encrypted systems.” Encryption, it turns out, is not a costly option, and Russell says it has had no detrimental effect on his keyboards’ performance.

Solving the problem

Though all of these problems were frustrating, Russell says he was able to find another vendor who could solve them: Wireless Computing of Austin, Texas. The company incorporates two-way, encrypted, RF communications in all of their keyboards and mice, and they all have a 100 foot operating range. In addition, Wireless Computing stores address ID settings on an EEPROM that will hold its memory if the batteries die or are removed.

“There are a lot of folks using the conference rooms every day,” says Russell, “and they shouldn’t have to waste their valuable time calling the help desk for something as simple as a keyboard or mouse." Russell is not necessarily endorsing Wireless Computing, but he does suggest that the features they include as standard are, in fact, what you need to look for in whatever brand of keyboard or mouse you choose. “I will say so far they’re the best ones that I’ve found,” Russell explains. “The main points you need, however, are the two-way wireless communications, the hundred foot range, encryption, and the retention of the ID address. Having all this, they fit our needs perfectly.”

Disclaimer

Views expressed in this article by Mr. Russell are his alone, and do not constitute an endorsement, either expressed or implied, by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.

Copyright 2007, New Bay Media, LLC. Used by permission.

Home
Products
Customers
News
Order
Support
Reviews
About Us
Contact Us
512-858-4400